24 Feb 2025

light mode

Vitalik Buterin’s Fresh Take on Ethereum

Vitalik Buterin’s Fresh Take on Ethereum

Vitalik Buterin, the mastermind and driving force behind Ethereum, seems to recognize that the digital giant he helped build is becoming unruly. To bring structure to this decentralized empire, immediate action is essential.

On this page

The challenges facing the Ethereum ecosystem were highlighted in our article, “Ethereum Ecosystem: Challenges and Contradictions.” It turns out these concerns were far from baseless—the platform's flaws are well understood, even by its co-founders.

A recent blog post by Ethereum's creator and visionary, Vitalik Buterin, serves as confirmation of this understanding.

In the post, Buterin outlines the urgent steps that need to be taken to keep the ecosystem afloat. He points to the lack of coordination between Layer 2 projects as a major bottleneck for smooth operation and the development of new decentralized applications.

Vitalik Buterin's Vision for the Future

In Vitalik’s view, the main challenge for the Ethereum community is to bring together all developer teams and their projects into a well-coordinated system. He likens the ecosystem to a massive city, where each district (project) develops under a unified set of rules. 

The goal is to create harmony between these districts, ensuring they work together and complement each other, building a single, thriving metropolis—rather than a collection of isolated villages where each developer operates independently.

Read more: Vitalik Buterin: Perfect Nerd.

To achieve this seamless cooperation, Vitalik introduces the concept of “alignment.” This means that all projects should adhere to common values and standards. For example, every protocol should remain open-source (allowing everyone to review and suggest improvements), prioritize decentralization, and focus on serving the public good.

However, Buterin warns against a rigid interpretation of “alignment.” Sometimes, the term is misused to create exclusive circles, where only certain people or projects are deemed “correct.” This, he argues, is the opposite of what decentralization stands for.

Ethereum’s ecosystem as a unified metropolis. Source: marcos.antonio

Ethereum’s ecosystem as a unified metropolis. Source: marcos.antonio

Straightening Out Layer 2? No Problem!

To make the idea of “alignment” more practical and understandable for everyone involved, Buterin suggests breaking it down into a few key elements, which can be expressed as clear metrics.

Here are several criteria a project must meet to be considered “aligned.”

1. Open-Source Code. This is the cornerstone of trust and progress within the ecosystem. When the code is open, anyone can inspect it for vulnerabilities and propose improvements. This ensures the project is safeguarded from hidden flaws, fraud, or manipulation. While not every part of an application needs to be public, the essential components that affect the entire ecosystem must be accessible to all.

2. Unified Standards. For projects across the ecosystem to work together smoothly, there need to be common ground rules. Standards like ERC-20 for tokens already exist, but they're just the beginning. New universal guidelines need to be developed to tackle future challenges.

3. Genuine Decentralization. For the system to be truly decentralized and secure, it must be resistant to failures and attacks. This means the network should never rely on any single point of control or a select group of individuals.

Read more: Decentralization Concerns in the Ethereum Ecosystem

Vitalik proposes two key tests to assess both decentralization and security:

  • The Resilience Test. This test asks whether a project can continue operating if its original team were to suddenly vanish. If the project can function independently without the creators' involvement, it is considered decentralized enough.
  • The Attack Test. In this test, the Layer 2 development team attempts to breach their own protocol. How difficult is it to compromise the system? If the project can resist attacks from its own creators, it's deemed highly secure.

4. Commitment to the Greater Good. Ethereum-based projects should aim to benefit the entire community, not just enrich their creators. This means that the success of one project should contribute to the growth of the whole ecosystem. For instance, a project could utilize Ethereum’s native token (ETH) in its operations, increasing demand for the token and supporting the broader network. Additionally, projects should consider donating a portion of their profits to fund public initiatives within the Ethereum ecosystem.

Buterin plans to set standards for Layer 2 projects. Source: cryptonews

Buterin plans to set standards for Layer 2 projects. Source: cryptonews

How Will L2 Projects Be Assessed?

In the view of Ethereum’s chief architect, the system he designed is meant to create new opportunities for the entire crypto community and address significant global financial challenges. Every Layer 2 (L2) project should contribute to this mission, whether by expanding access to financial services, developing technologies that solve problems beyond the crypto space, or supporting social initiatives.

To objectively evaluate the contributions of each development team, a rating system similar to L2beat will be introduced. This system will monitor how well each project aligns with key parameters: how decentralized it is, how secure it is, and how much value it brings to the community. Projects that achieve the highest scores will be promoted by the Ethereum Foundation, receiving additional resources and gaining the foundation’s direct support.

Read more: Vitalik Buterin Reveals Plans for the Ethereum Purge

The Ethereum Foundation will help facilitate the creation of these rating systems, but it will not control them. The criteria will be defined by the community itself, fostering a transparent and fair ecosystem where projects compete based on merit rather than simply trying to appeal to their target audience. This will create a more open and equitable system for distributing resources.

For the evaluation system to be effective, the criteria must be clearly outlined. Vague standards could lead to subjective assessments and potentially negative consequences. 

Vitalik is not yet ready to propose specific details but suggests opening this topic for wider discussion.

Will all 22 Ethereum Foundation employees have a say in this approach? There is no definitive answer yet, and such a move could spark criticism, as it may clash with the core principle of decentralization.

Still, there is little doubt that establishing a transparent rating system for L2 projects will make the entire ecosystem more fair and efficient, which in turn will attract more users and developers.

The content on The Coinomist is for informational purposes only and should not be interpreted as financial advice. While we strive to provide accurate and up-to-date information, we do not guarantee the accuracy, completeness, or reliability of any content. Neither we accept liability for any errors or omissions in the information provided or for any financial losses incurred as a result of relying on this information. Actions based on this content are at your own risk. Always do your own research and consult a professional. See our Terms, Privacy Policy, and Disclaimers for more details.

Articles by this author
 eXch Caught in Crypto Crime Allegations—Bybit Hack Connection?

 eXch Caught in Crypto Crime Allegations—Bybit Hack Connection?

Authorities have accused eXch of processing illicit transactions linked to Lazarus Group, following the Bybit hack that drained $1.4 billion. The exchange refutes the claims, but forensic evidence is raising red flags.

Anton Kryshtal
SEC Retreat Marks Pivotal Legal Win for Crypto Firms

SEC Retreat Marks Pivotal Legal Win for Crypto Firms

The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission has withdrawn its appeal in the case regarding the expansion of the “Dealer Rule” to encompass crypto companies, a move that critics argue may alleviate excessive regulatory constraints.

Anton Kryshtal
Bankman-Fried Seeks GOP Ties Amid Clemency Talks

Bankman-Fried Seeks GOP Ties Amid Clemency Talks

Former FTX CEO Sam Bankman-Fried recently gave an interview that stirred controversy, even from behind bars, where he is serving a 25-year sentence for massive crypto fraud.

The Coinomist
Binance Faces $81.5 Billion Lawsuit in Nigeria Over Taxes

Binance Faces $81.5 Billion Lawsuit in Nigeria Over Taxes

Nigeria’s government is suing Binance, accusing it of causing significant economic damage and tax evasion, with a demand for an $81.5 billion fine.

Anton Kryshtal
Weekly Analysis of BTC, ETH, and the Stock Market (Feb 18, 2025)

Weekly Analysis of BTC, ETH, and the Stock Market (Feb 18, 2025)

An overview of BTC, ETH, XAUT, and S&P500 charts, and the current cryptocurrency market dynamics.

Artem Khomenko
Weekly Analysis of BTC, ETH, and the Stock Market (Feb 10, 2025)

Weekly Analysis of BTC, ETH, and the Stock Market (Feb 10, 2025)

An overview of BTC, ETH, XAUT, and S&P500 charts, and the current cryptocurrency market dynamics.

Artem Khomenko
Weekly Analysis of BTC, ETH, and the Stock Market (Feb 3, 2025)

Weekly Analysis of BTC, ETH, and the Stock Market (Feb 3, 2025)

An overview of BTC, ETH, XAUT, and S&P500 charts, and the current cryptocurrency market dynamics.

Artem Khomenko
Crypto Arbitrage Explained: Is It Worth the Investment?

Crypto Arbitrage Explained: Is It Worth the Investment?

In the rapidly evolving world of cryptocurrency, one term you’re likely to encounter is staking. For crypto enthusiasts and investors, staking offers an opportunity.

The Coinomist
What Is Staking in Crypto? 

What Is Staking in Crypto? 

In the rapidly evolving world of cryptocurrency, one term you’re likely to encounter is staking. For crypto enthusiasts and investors, staking offers an opportunity.

The Coinomist
Solayer: A Cutting-Edge Restaking Protocol on Solana

Solayer: A Cutting-Edge Restaking Protocol on Solana

Solayer expands Solana’s blockchain capabilities through restaking, offering advanced security solutions for dApps. While development started in spring 2024, the project gained significant attention only recently after the LAYER token airdrop.

The Coinomist
How to Bump a Transaction in the Bitcoin Network

How to Bump a Transaction in the Bitcoin Network

Sometimes, Bitcoin transactions can get “stuck,” especially if a low fee was set. In such cases, you might wonder: Why is my Bitcoin transaction stuck?

bitOn
Inside Cryptocurrency Farms: How Digital Coins Are Mined

Inside Cryptocurrency Farms: How Digital Coins Are Mined

Cryptocurrency farms and mining have evolved significantly since Bitcoin launched in 2009. To understand their growth, it helps to look at the broader history of resource extraction.

The Coinomist
From Bulls to Ballers — Why Celebrities Are Flocking to Crypto

From Bulls to Ballers — Why Celebrities Are Flocking to Crypto

Trump’s meme coin isn’t an outlier—it’s part of a broader trend. Back in 2021, celebrities were minting NFTs, and by 2024, they had moved on to personal token launches. The connection between fame and crypto has been growing for years, even if many failed to see it.

Vlad Vovk
Coinbase Is Expanding Crypto Futures—But Who Really Wins?

Coinbase Is Expanding Crypto Futures—But Who Really Wins?

Coinbase is expanding its presence in the crypto derivatives market by introducing new futures contracts on Solana and Hedera.

Anahit Avetisyan
Crypto Fraud in Norway: When Will Investors Learn?

Crypto Fraud in Norway: When Will Investors Learn?

Norwegian authorities have charged four men with running a massive crypto scam that defrauded thousands of investors out of NOK 900 million (about $86.5 million).

Anahit Avetisyan
MORE
«Mass Adoption Isn’t About Tech – It’s About Perception». Bitmedia Founder Matvii Diadkov – About RWA, Web3, And Marketing

«Mass Adoption Isn’t About Tech – It’s About Perception». Bitmedia Founder Matvii Diadkov – About RWA, Web3, And Marketing

Matvii Diadkov, founder of Bitmedia, shared with us in an exclusive interview his expert insights on Web3 adoption, impact of GameFi and community-centering tendencies in the market.

The Coinomist
“Satoshi is CIA”: Swedish crypto bro opens up about his Bitcoin journey

“Satoshi is CIA”: Swedish crypto bro opens up about his Bitcoin journey

The first crypto craze took place almost a decade ago. Overnight, many people found out about Bitcoin and its underlying technology, blockchain.

Lesia Dubenko
MORE